Dear Tanya
I read your book “People In Glass Houses” and I have to say, I was impressed. You’ve got an amazing story to tell and you do it with such passion and such guts, that I am filled with admiration. I had some issues with it that I’ve outlined in my review for Popmatters, but they’re trivial in the grand scheme of things. All said, though, it was a hard book for me to read because it reminded me so much of my own upbringing and my own journey this far.
There are some big differences, obviously. I figure from the chronology of your book that you’re about ten years older than me (I’m 26) so we grew up in slightly different eras – I listened guiltily to Pearl Jam instead of Bruce Springsteen. And my parents took me to a wide range of churches, most of them not Pentecostal. We spent most of 1992 in various churches that had two-hours of worship followed by a fiery sermon and we copped the Toronto Blessing in the mid 90s (I think you were probably away from the church in those days – but you didn’t miss anything).
Still, I feel like we’d understand each other pretty well. The same kind of guilt-trips and mixed-messages made my teens a very conflicted place to be and have stayed with me to this day. The same kind of contradictions and wilful ignorance offended my intellect. The same fakeness made me doubt myself and drove me away from those around me in church.
So the surprising thing to me is that I’m still around, calling myself a Christian and going to church every week, while you’ve pretty much burnt your bridges. Maybe your doubts were bigger and your negative experiences more dramatic. Perhaps your lifestyle choices made you more ostracised than mine have. Maybe there’s no God after all and you’re just smarter than me.
I struggled a bit after finishing your book. It hit me at a time when I was annoyed at my fellow Christians for the usual reasons and feeling pretty negative. You reminded me of the 268 reasons why I am tempted to chuck the whole thing in on an almost daily basis.
Yet a strange thing happened in the last two weeks. I remembered the one reason why I stick around and how it somehow outweighs all the others.
I just don’t know how any of this makes sense without the idea that there’s a God who looked at the mess that we people have made of what he gave us and decided that drastic measures were called for; who called a bunch of people out of a Middle Eastern desert and said that they were going to show the world how things should be done; and who actually rolled up his sleeves, came down here and explained it all in the most extreme piece of interpretive dance you’ll ever see. Because that story gives me a reason to hope that things are going to get better. Because it fits with the changes that I’ve seen in myself and other people around me as they start to understand that story better and start to live it out day to day.
To a lot of people, that sounds ridiculous, even offensive. It does to me some days, too. But it’s got a hold on me that I can’t shake.
At the end of your book, you make a reference to the Emerging Church that’s popping up around the place where people are trying to fix up some of the mistakes we’ve made in the past and get back to what Jesus meant 2000 years ago. I’m trying to be a part of that and I figure it’s worth a shot. After all – it might just help me work out what I’m still doing here after everything.
I hope that your questions get answered too.
Take care
Dave