Last month, one of my musical heroes passed through my city and I didn’t go and see him play. Part of that was because his recent music isn’t doing it for me like it used to. The other part was a slight feeling of betrayal, one that just won’t leave me.
See, David Bazan (formerly of Pedro the Lion) meant something very special to me once upon a time. It seemed like it was possible to be a serious, cool Christian guy, operating in the world of indie rock and being frank about your faith and your doubts. I’m someone with a LOT of doubt, but strong beliefs as well - a contradiction and a tension that makes it a little difficult to fit in with either the believers or the unbelievers. Pedro the Lion’s songs captured that feeling.
Now maybe I had him up on too high a pedestal, one Bazan would have been the first to tell me to get him right off. I sang “Of Minor Prophets and Their Prostitute Wives” to a bible study (easier than preparing a study on Haggai, and catchier). I quoted “The Secret of the Easy Yoke” in a sermon. I loved his irreverence mixed with deep conviction. He seemed to be like me, only cooler and more talented. The only way from that kind of adulation is down.
But last year when I was in Seattle, I read an interview in the local indie rag where Bazan said he no longer considered himself a Christian. He was an agnostic, probably. It was serendipitous - I was in Seattle for one week only and the story wasn’t reported widely - and it broke my heart a little bit. Clearly I’m not the only one who felt that way - Joel Hartse in the latest Patrol Magazine clearly went through all the same emotions.
For me, it was kind of like reading Tanya Levin’s journey into unbelief (blogged about here) last year, when I could see so many parallels with my own journey. When you see yourself walking down the same path as someone and then you see the destination they reach, it seems like only a matter of time before you get there too.
At the same time, it hardens my resolve not to end up where they have. It’s so easy to let your disillusionment win over, to let the shit you’ve seen distract you from the truth about Jesus. I heard a Rob Bell talk earlier this year when advised people to “doubt your doubts” - to subject your anger and questioning to the same critical thinking you put your beliefs and passions through. Because often they’re less well-grounded than the things you’ve held to all these years. Often they don’t hold up to any kind of scrutiny.
I don’t know what’s happened to David Bazan. I do know that I’m not him. I’m a different David and I’ve got my own path to follow and I suspect I’m going to like where it takes me.